Sunday, January 31, 2010
Goodnight
Okay so I am finally almost caught up on the reading and have thoroughly enjoyed The Things They Carried so far. This is by far my favorite novel we have read this year, or actually short stories. Many themes have come to my attention as I have been reading. One of the most obvious themes is O’Briens blending of the real and unreal, the tangible and the imaginative. This is most evident in the chapter How to Tell a True War Story. Constantly in the chapter O’Brien contradicts himself in an effort to convey the reason why soldiers need to tell their stories. O’Brien says, “And then afterward, when you go to tell about it, there is always that surreal seemingness, which makes the story seem untrue, but which in fact represents the hard and exact truth as it seemed”. “In other cases you can’t even tell a true war story. Sometimes it’s just beyond telling”. O'Brien's point in this story is that the real connection is between war and love. Something you would not exactly hear in your average war story. This theme is also evident in an earlier story. Lt. Cross believes that because he loves Martha, he does not fulfill his duty toward his men. He literally thinks that because he chose love over war, Ted Lavender is dead. O'Brien believes, however, that love comes with the territory of war. As we are reading the stories its hard to remember the work is a collection of fiction. I struggle as I want to believe the stories are true.. I feel for the soldiers and the pain of war and suffering. This is exactly what O’Brien wants to accomplish in writing these stories. He wants others to understand what its like to go through a war. And that’s what telling a True War Story is all about.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Very good blog as always combs!! I really like when you beought in the idea of how you said, "One of the most obvious themes is O’Briens blending of the real and unreal, the tangible and the imaginative." This really brings out descritive imagery that lets me think of what the picture could have really looked like. It can depictr the real events that happened during the war and how we may not alwasy have the true story. I also liek your idea on how "O'Brien's point in this story is that the real connection is between war and love." This really explains the meaning of how the soldiers felt and it brings something to my mind if someone really loves something enough they would die for it. That ios why the soldiers love war because they love their country and they are willing to give their life up for it. Again...very good blog.
ReplyDeleteNice job Combs. You really did a good job summing up what you think the overall theme of the novel is. At first I didn’t really understand what you were talking about, but after reading your blog all the way through I now feel that I have a better understanding. I agree that O’Brien has been explaining the real and the unreal throughout his short stories, but if I wouldn’t have read your blog I would have never thought that it was a major theme. I also really liked how you concluded when you talked about how O’Brien’s ultimate goal is to help the reader understand exactly what was going on throughout the war. Way to go Combs!
ReplyDelete